Wednesday, 4 July 2007

Man dies on Ben Nevis - addition

On Monday, I wrote an entry Man dies on Ben Nevis, about a walker who suffered a heart attack whilst ascending Ben Nevis, and later died. I had a reaction from AOL user twigi1000 who was in the party with the man who unfortunately lost his life last Saturday. I quote:
I was in the same party as the gentleman who lost his life on Ben Nevis at the weekend and I am upset to find people speculating on the cause of his death.  I can inform you and anyone else who reads this blog that the gentleman in question was very fit and had trained hard for this challenge.  The group were attempting the three peak challenge for which the gentlman in question had completed successfully 2 years previous.  The team were well prepared and had extremely experienced leaders.

I completely agree that people do attempt these challenges without the proper training and equipment however on this occasion it was just down to bad luck.  He had a loving family and I don't think it is fair on them for people to assume he hadn't prepared properly.

Thanks
#2 Comment from twigi1000 - 04/07/07 15:02
I want to place on record that I have no reasons to assume that poor preparation, leadership or fitness had anything to do with the gentleman's untimely death, and my comments were not intended to hint in that direction at all. I sincerely apologise for any distress caused by my comments, which was wholly unintentional, and would like to extend my condoleances towards family and friends of the victim of this unfortunate incident.

I report incidents and events across the Highlands and Islands to reflect what goes on here, and to some extent also to educate or at least raise awareness. As so often in the land of blogging, you have to be ever so careful in your choice of words, particularly if you are discussing fatalities. I got it wrong this time.

8 comments:

  1. Thanks for posting this Guido.  I'd love to hear what your experiences were like on your own climb.  All we heard here was that the man, though prepared and somewhat experienced, just had a very unfortunate accident which couldn't have been foreseen or prepared for.  Either way, this mountain seems very unpredictable.  Stay well.  xoxo CATHY

    ReplyDelete
  2. We know you would never do anything to offend Guido, you only reported the incident.  Climbing is always hazardous and unpredictable.  Nice of you to make this gesture.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I remember looking at this mountain some weeks ago Guido when I was touring Scotland and in the course of seconds, as I took photographs, clouds obscured the summit and then it appeared again as quickly.  It made me reflect on what true conditions must be like right at the top for any climbers.  It was obvious to me,  a mere low fell walker in the Lakes, that Ben Nevis was a majestic but ominous and dangerous place for the unwary. It looked so dark, gloomy and cold.
    How very sad for this fit and athletetic climber to have suffered a heart attack whilst ascending it.  His day amongst like-minded friends must have began so eager, hopeful and happy.  
    My condolences too to his family and friends. May God Bless him.
    Jeanie

    ReplyDelete
  4. Guido,I read the piece you wrote and don't see how anyone could have been offended by the entry.Nevertheless, with this entry you once again prove to be a man of integrity.Keep up the good work :-) Shauneen

    ReplyDelete
  5. I did not mean for my entry dated 4th July to be a personal attack on you and I hope it hasn't been taken in this way. Your entry is very informative and your intentions were only to educate people on the hazards of climbing Ben Nevis.  

    I should have chosen some of my wording more carefully and I hope I haven't detracted people away from your true intentions which were to educate and hopefully save lives.

    I just felt it neccessary to point out that in this case a lack of preperation was not the cause of this trajedy.

    All the best,



    ReplyDelete
  6. Regarding previous comment: point taken. Choosing words is like grappling with an eel - they can snake off in unexpected directions. No offense taken, and discussion closed :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm glad that you talked of this, AND, that twigi1000 let us know his viewpoint as well (which, ultimately, is similar, but still nice for the discussion).  My sympathies go out to twigi1000 and others who knew and cared for Ben Nevis.  -- Robin

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh... I didn't take it that you meant that specific man was unprepared either.  Condolences to his friends and family.

    be well,
    Dawn
    http://journals.aol.com/princesssaurora/CarpeDiem/

    ReplyDelete